Last seen: April 11, 2026 9:32 pm
Knights are a pretty stacked team but other than ponga their spine is garbage. And ponga doesn’t come across as particularly a great team player or le...
My main reason for moving on brooks now and going with madden was the fact I think brooks isn’t a halfback who is worth anywhere near his current cont...
It will be interesting whether brooks chooses to stay with a downgrade or go to a club desperate for a halfback like the knights, dolphins or dragons....
Isn’t gildart meant to be signing with the dolphins in 23?
Sheens spoke about playing a system throughout the club. Would assume that means peachey comes in as a ball playing creative lock rather than joffa as...
The mole: Sheens' big call The wily old fox Tim Sheens has pretty much left Brett Kimmorley to his own devices since he took over the reins at the Ti...
Wests need marquee players to go with the development players. If 6 , 9 and 13 are decided the 7 and 1 are the positions for a marquee signing. Jury s...
Fair to say that Hastings is seen as the starting 13 and Douhie the starting 6 under sheens. Are we better off trying to turn brooks back to the pl...
Squad player
It’s not about 23. This is Ofcourse correct for 23 but what are you paying brooks for 24 and beyond. If he wants too much or if you don’t see him as t...
it’s obvious sheens etc wants brooks to stay. The same as every coach over the last 10 years. It’s not so much about 2023, but 2024 and beyond. If bro...
Brooks vs madden on 50% brooks salary. not that hard
Madden has a good kicking and short passing and knows how to read a game but needs work in defence. He is the anti-brooks
Might regret it but I think he plays well and it becomes evident we don’t need brooks. We trade out brooks over off season and we keep madden and put ...