It was almost predictable - we don't seem to be able to get up for lowly rated teams and our CSS record is atrocious. As you point out, the crowd was ...

Most people have this one right. We desperately need a game manager. Madden and AD aren't game managers and it's not a mentality you simply create. ...

Any progress?

You're beyond reason. Life's too short.

Agreed. He was very ordinary at dummy half - his passing game is poor - but when he started to run a bit in the second half he was much better. If ...

That is terrible news. It certainly didn't look good.

If you don't believe mistakes cost games I cite the Titans game (Madden didn't ground the ball and conceded a try) and the game where Laurie dropped i...

Thank you.

The joys of a free society is we can disagree. His first half could have cost us the game. I've not read one comment saying he played well for the f...

Correct. If Hastings and Doueihi were excelling at 7 and 6 I doubt people would be calling for Madden to play half. It seems more an anti-Brooks sen...

Well, it's not my decision, just my opinion.

He's defensively inferior to any other halfback option we have. That's a significant loss. I can't.

A point often overlooked.

I don't want to sound like I'm singling him out but his first half was terrible. His second half, like last week, was very good. You can't be sensat...

3 - Hastings 2 - Kelma 1 - Joffa HM. Laurie, Seyfarth, AJ, To'a, Pole. Pretty solid across the pitch.