voice_of_reason
@voice_of_reason
Balmain Tigers SG Ball
Joined: February 5, 2022 9:47 am
Last seen: March 4, 2023 5:38 pm
Topics: 6 / Replies: 402
Reply
RE: WT vs Warriors Round 16

Interesting, this is what I suggested yesterday. Flattering to think Noddy or Sheens are getting their advice from a numpty on a forum. The logic is s...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

I know nothing about Kade Dyes but people suggest he has ability. Having Dykes and Laurie as options at both fullback and 6 is good news. Brooks may b...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Good grief... Staines has played a total of one good game - against us.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

This is a very fair and accurate assessment and pretty much aligns with my position. I genuinely hope we can find a spot where he shines but in my e...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

We'll have to disagree then.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

2022 - we now need better players around him.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Why? How many people thought we were a chance for Papal'i or Api? Money talks and we've worked our way into a strong cap position. AD is (reporte...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

I'm not devaluing or writing him off. What I'm saying is we signed him as a fullback (on fullback money) and he was poor. Now we have to 'find' a posi...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: WT vs Warriors Round 16

This game has disaster written all over it but I thought the same thing about the first round games against Parramatta and Souths. It's highly unlik...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

I agree with this. His footy smarts aren't great and as someone said elsewhere, he seems to pre-meditate moves which leads to poor decisions - like ...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

This is key for me although often overlooked. We buy players for a position and when they don't work out we try to manufacture them into something t...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

I disagree, he improved the team when moved to centre. I would entertain Laurie at 6 before AD but as we don't have a viable fullback option it won't ...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

I don't want him chased out, I just don't see where he fits. Despite what he believes, he's not proven at 6 and he's clearly not a fullback (which, ...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Luke Brooks Poll

Similar money to Burton - as much as I like AD I know which I'd prefer.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Seems a very nice man, hard worker and always put in (sometimes to his own detriment). Sadly though his time has come. Retire for your own good Elij...

2 years ago
Page 13 / 28