One one hand, I see Gildart as somewhat handicapped in the NRL due to his physical size.On the other hand, I see a smart footy player. And I'm totally...

I reckon you're a tough judge, Unhap. Melbourne had really good shape on that play with an extra player coming in behind on a straight line. I think h...

Yep, classic Ayoub. Needs to be put on a lie detector for negotiations..

Simpkin and Peachey both fit? They looked to have shoulder issue against Storm…

I know a bit late (just watched replay) but would vote 3 Joe 2 Ken 1 Stephano

I agree but we'd have made a move already if that interested.

Can we leave it open longer than Tuesday for those of us needing to get time to watch a replay?

At his best I agree, but seems to be off the pace at this point for some reason.

Certainly weren't the progress scores I expected to hear. Ended up half respectable.

I think we've moved on dead wood and replaced it with better options eg Peachy and positive changes in the coaches. So I've gone for a slight improvem...

Pele would help us build the pack we need for the modern game, so I'd pay some overs. Not ridiculous though.

3rd option? I'm struggling to keep either!

I agree with the forming consensus that while he probably is not going to be a star NRL player, he definitely should be retained for this year. I thin...

This is certainly going to throw a spanner into the works. Selection will be interesting as it'll be likely Peachy will need to spend some time at 9, ...

Yep, surely Smith has had an influence on how Rua plays.