Luke Garner’s defence has been a revelation over the last year.On the weekend he was pressuring Tommy Turbo to great effect.He seems calm and contained and his hands don’t let him down as they have in the past.He’s served his apprenticeship and ironed out his foibles.....I’m dumbfounded we didn’t counter-offer to retain him.That snake Cleary is being gifted a ready made,versatile quality player at a bargain price as a 26,27 year old with EXPERIENCE!
I know we purportedly have some young guns coming through,but how long does it take to get them up to speed?
Perhaps there are some diamonds that we can’t afford to lose and it’s dictated by salary cap balance,but I agree,hard to swallow with the fact we’re losing Kelma and big Lucy,our best forward.
Luke Garner’s defence has been a revelation over the last year.On the weekend he was pressuring Tommy Turbo to great effect.He seems calm and contained and his hands don’t let him down as they have in the past.He’s served his apprenticeship and ironed out his foibles.....I’m dumbfounded we didn’t counter-offer to retain him.That snake Cleary is being gifted a ready made,versatile quality player at a bargain price as a 26,27 year old with EXPERIENCE!
I know we purportedly have some young guns coming through,but how long does it take to get them up to speed?
Perhaps there are some diamonds that we can’t afford to lose and it’s dictated by salary cap balance,but I agree,hard to swallow with the fact we’re losing Kelma and big Lucy,our best forward.
In Sheens we trust?
Wests Tigers Podcast - Talking everything Wests Tigers!
Luke Garner’s defence has been a revelation over the last year.On the weekend he was pressuring Tommy Turbo to great effect.He seems calm and contained and his hands don’t let him down as they have in the past.He’s served his apprenticeship and ironed out his foibles.....I’m dumbfounded we didn’t counter-offer to retain him.That snake Cleary is being gifted a ready made,versatile quality player at a bargain price as a 26,27 year old with EXPERIENCE!
I know we purportedly have some young guns coming through,but how long does it take to get them up to speed?
Perhaps there are some diamonds that we can’t afford to lose and it’s dictated by salary cap balance,but I agree,hard to swallow with the fact we’re losing Kelma and big Lucy,our best forward.
In Sheens we trust?
Ha,ha,ha..although I liked what I saw from I.Papali’i against Penrith.
Disappointing regarding Nikora. Lots of pressure on us now to sign Crichton (Or anyone good) otherwise we’ll look ridiculous letting Leilua, Tuilgai and Garner.
Yep ..especially Garner .....Luch and Tuilagi are better players .....but leaving yourself short a starting back row for 2023 is unforgivable
Few stories going around that the Roosters want to clean house ...letting go JWH Crichton etc go to make a run at Munster ...
Id take JWH at the right price. Old and past it but still a hard loose unit and we lack that.
I think he is past it ....I reckon he is battling to get 30 quality minutes now ...I think he turns 35 before next season starts ...I'd pass .....18 months ago ...hell yeah
Im sure you are right, just have always wanted that type of player here
It seems we offered Nikora just shy of $600k a year for 3 years ($1.7M), Cronulla have matched it.
If Crichton is on the market how much higher are we willing to go to get him? To me he is a much better option.
@cqtiger if we offered 600k for Nikora Crichton would easily be a 750k player mike's better than nikora
I know I am bad on the mail Sharks contact I have e.g. Pele looked to be over the line now not so sure.
Apparently I have been told we are in talks with Caleb Clarke All Black and Auckland Blues winger. No idea on salary etc but looking at 2024 after rugby world cup. Madge has met with Caleb apparently
Nikora staying at sharks
The Mole saying Newcastle's Tex Hoy is being shopped. Any interest?
Wests Tigers Podcast - Talking everything Wests Tigers!
@helmesy Daine Laurie is a better player and I would rather give the back up to someone with potential like Dykes.
@helmesy Daine Laurie is a better player and I would rather give the back up to someone with potential like Dykes.
Is he the son of Adam Dykes?
Wests Tigers Podcast - Talking everything Wests Tigers!
Disappointing regarding Nikora. Lots of pressure on us now to sign Crichton (Or anyone good) otherwise we’ll look ridiculous letting Leilua, Tuilgai and Garner.
Yep ..especially Garner .....Luch and Tuilagi are better players .....but leaving yourself short a starting back row for 2023 is unforgivable
Few stories going around that the Roosters want to clean house ...letting go JWH Crichton etc go to make a run at Munster ...
Id take JWH at the right price. Old and past it but still a hard loose unit and we lack that.
I think he is past it ....I reckon he is battling to get 30 quality minutes now ...I think he turns 35 before next season starts ...I'd pass .....18 months ago ...hell yeah
Im sure you are right, just have always wanted that type of player here
We had em .....McCracken ....Dwyer ....Fifita ....Nathan Brown .....dare I say it Lodge ....
Disappointing regarding Nikora. Lots of pressure on us now to sign Crichton (Or anyone good) otherwise we’ll look ridiculous letting Leilua, Tuilgai and Garner.
Yep ..especially Garner .....Luch and Tuilagi are better players .....but leaving yourself short a starting back row for 2023 is unforgivable
Few stories going around that the Roosters want to clean house ...letting go JWH Crichton etc go to make a run at Munster ...
Id take JWH at the right price. Old and past it but still a hard loose unit and we lack that.
I think he is past it ....I reckon he is battling to get 30 quality minutes now ...I think he turns 35 before next season starts ...I'd pass .....18 months ago ...hell yeah
Im sure you are right, just have always wanted that type of player here
We had em .....McCracken ....Dwyer ....Fifita ....Nathan Brown .....dare I say it Lodge ....
True, but never had them at their peak....
Disappointing regarding Nikora. Lots of pressure on us now to sign Crichton (Or anyone good) otherwise we’ll look ridiculous letting Leilua, Tuilgai and Garner.
Yep ..especially Garner .....Luch and Tuilagi are better players .....but leaving yourself short a starting back row for 2023 is unforgivable
Few stories going around that the Roosters want to clean house ...letting go JWH Crichton etc go to make a run at Munster ...
Id take JWH at the right price. Old and past it but still a hard loose unit and we lack that.
I think he is past it ....I reckon he is battling to get 30 quality minutes now ...I think he turns 35 before next season starts ...I'd pass .....18 months ago ...hell yeah
Im sure you are right, just have always wanted that type of player here
We had em .....McCracken ....Dwyer ....Fifita ....Nathan Brown .....dare I say it Lodge ....
True, but never had them at their peak....
Totally agree but we can only blame ourselves for some of those players not being here ....can we tempt Gareth Ellis back as an assistant coach
