Share:
Notifications
Clear all

Brooks or Madden

(@helmesy)
Wests Tigers Development Player Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 4738
Topic starter  

Luke Brooks has allegedly been trying to get out of the club and has another year to run on his contract.

Jock Madden is off contract at the end of 2022.

If you had to make a choice between the pair, which player would you keep?

Wests Tigers Podcast - Talking everything Wests Tigers!


   
Quote
(@Anonymous 79)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 1586
 

Plenty more upside with Madden… simples 


   
ReplyQuote
(@Anonymous 9)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3247
 

If I had to choose our halves now i'd probably run with Hastings and AD. I think they have the ability to create a bit more than Brooks and/or Madden. In saying that, Madden has only played a handful of NRL games so it's probably too early to make a call. He seems to try hard every game which is a good quality.

I think Brooks is a talented player that has been ruined in our system. I think a change of scenery would do him the world of good and I hope he has success wherever he goes.


   
ReplyQuote
(@Anonymous 77)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 402
 
Posted by: @avocadoontoast

If I had to choose our halves now i'd probably run with Hastings and AD. I think they have the ability to create a bit more than Brooks and/or Madden. In saying that, Madden has only played a handful of NRL games so it's probably too early to make a call. He seems to try hard every game which is a good quality.

I think Brooks is a talented player that has been ruined in our system. I think a change of scenery would do him the world of good and I hope he has success wherever he goes.

Yes I definitely think when Doueihi is back from injury priority needs to be given to him and Hastings in the halves going forward. 

Brooks just hasn’t got what the WestsTigers need and that is a confident halve back that can lead and direct this team around the field, so I’m more then happy to call it a day with Brooks and let him and the WestsTigers move on.

I’d re-sign Madden for about another 12 mths as a back up. His still a work in progress with  his defence etc.

Keeping in mind that we have future talent coming through the ranks in the halves as well. So we don’t want to lose them by making the same mistakes of the past by signing the wrong players now. 


   
Joel Helmes reacted
ReplyQuote
(@jedi-tiger)
Wests Tigers Development Player
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 4338
 

Clearly Luke Brooks by the length of the straight

next year we have

9 Api

7 Brooks 

6 Douhie

13 Hastings 

we need a fullback 

that is a good spine

 


   
ReplyQuote
Frullens
(@frullens)
Wests Tigers Jersey Flegg Moderator
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 1749
 
Posted by: @jedi-tiger

Clearly Luke Brooks by the length of the straight

next year we have

9 Api

7 Brooks 

6 Douhie

13 Hastings 

we need a fullback 

that is a good spine

 

I keep changing my mind but I'd have

9 Api

7 Hastings

6 Brooks

13 AD

Top 8 2023


   
ReplyQuote
(@Anonymous 9)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3247
 

Realistically next year we have two very good players in our spine, being Api and AD. We are desperate for a proper 7 who can control the game. It’s definitely not Brooks and I’m not sure about Madden.

When AD is back maybe try him at 6 with Madden at 7 and Hastings at 13 and see how it goes. This year is a good opportunity to try out some combos.

As for fullback I haven’t given up on Laurie but he’s been disappointing this year for sure. 


   
Roachy reacted
ReplyQuote
(@kenny4517)
Balmain Tigers SG Ball
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 343
 

Brooks is not an organiser. He is a runner. He is not a halfback. The good halves play chess on the field. No one taught Brooks how to play. We desperately need organising halfback & a fullback.


   
Mac_Tiger, Enumerator, Unhappy Tiger and 1 people reacted
ReplyQuote
(@roachy)
Wests Tigers Supporter
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 26
 

Went Brooks, however I'm not confident in either 


 


   
Joel Helmes reacted
ReplyQuote
(@jedi-tiger)
Wests Tigers Development Player
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 4338
 

@frullens that works too frullens

either way we have a good 6 7 9 13 

fullback is our problem 


   
Frullens reacted
ReplyQuote
(@unhappy-tiger)
Wests Tigers Jersey Flegg
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 1226
 

Why am I always looking for Option C ??

 

I'm leaning towards Madden ......Brooks has had many years to cement his spot 


   
ReplyQuote
(@Anonymous 9)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3247
 
Posted by: @unhappy-tiger

Why am I always looking for Option C ??

 

I'm leaning towards Madden ......Brooks has had many years to cement his spot 

I think we should be throwing everything we’ve got at Munster.


   
ReplyQuote
(@unhappy-tiger)
Wests Tigers Jersey Flegg
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 1226
 
Posted by: @avocadoontoast
Posted by: @unhappy-tiger

Why am I always looking for Option C ??

 

I'm leaning towards Madden ......Brooks has had many years to cement his spot 

I think we should be throwing everything we’ve got at Munster.

Something fishy with Munster .....Melbourne wanting him to take a pay cut ....Redcliffe Brisbane or the Cows not chasing hard for him 

Maybe he is unfixable off field wise .....someone mentioned to me a while ago maybe he is an alcoholic ....explains a bit ....


   
ReplyQuote
(@Anonymous 9)
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3247
 
Posted by: @unhappy-tiger
Posted by: @avocadoontoast
Posted by: @unhappy-tiger

Why am I always looking for Option C ??

 

I'm leaning towards Madden ......Brooks has had many years to cement his spot 

I think we should be throwing everything we’ve got at Munster.

Something fishy with Munster .....Melbourne wanting him to take a pay cut ....Redcliffe Brisbane or the Cows not chasing hard for him 

Maybe he is unfixable off field wise .....someone mentioned to me a while ago maybe he is an alcoholic ....explains a bit ....

I’m not sure what the issue is, he’s a hell of a player though. Given where we are we don’t really have much to lose. I’d be going hard at him. He’s a winner.


   
Joel Helmes reacted
ReplyQuote
Enumerator
(@enumerator)
Junior Pathways
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 131
 

How has this club not resigned Madden.

The guy has skills, Desire and the courage to organise.

I don't understand this !


   
Mike reacted
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2
Share: