voice_of_reason
@voice_of_reason
Balmain Tigers SG Ball
Joined: February 5, 2022 9:47 am
Last seen: March 4, 2023 5:38 pm
Topics: 6 / Replies: 402
Reply
RE: Sunday Night Live Round 18 (Live Thread)

Just remember we had as many starters out as they did - and they have greater depth.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Sunday Night Live Round 18 (Live Thread)

I can't listen anymore, I clearly watched a different game. AD was poor in the first half, he was far from our best. Brooks creates the space with s...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Sunday Night Live Round 18 (Live Thread)

Declan, AD had the slowest PTB average of the entire team.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: The Halves Conundrum (3 into 2)

I agree with all this except the part about being a 6. If he had the speed and agility of Wighton or Burton maybe, but he doesn't.

2 years ago
Reply
Reply
RE: The Halves Conundrum (3 into 2)

I'm not sure I follow as Hastings hasn't played 6 (maybe first game). AD was playing wide.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: The Halves Conundrum (3 into 2)

We can only judge what's in front of us but it's hard to properly assess until we have a legitimately competitive pack. All three in question would ...

2 years ago
Topic
2 years ago
Forum
NRL
Replies: 1
Views: 895
Reply
RE: The Halves Conundrum (3 into 2)

He played well in the second half but his first half was poor. His kicking was ad-hoc and without purpose and he had some mediocre reads in defence. ...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: The Halves Conundrum (3 into 2)

I agree. The club is pandering to Doueihi and it will likely cost us Hastings whose smarts we need. AD should be playing centre or edge forward. His...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Live game day thread v Panthers Rd18 *Spoilers

Saved a couple of tries, had some great touches and set up a try in a position he's played a total of... once. We need more plodders like him. He's...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Live game day thread v Panthers Rd18 *Spoilers

We do it because his speed is what's creating space on the edges. Neither AD or Hastings has the speed to do the fast wrap and Laurie isn't always the...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Live game day thread v Panthers Rd18 *Spoilers

I agree on Kelma but not Garner - he's been very good this year and does a lot of tidying up. I hope his knee is OK.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Did Wests Tigers make the right choice?

Everything above could be said for Madge. Sacking the coach is essentially endorsing the playing group - other wise you'd sack them.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Round 18 Man of the Match Voting

3 - Hastings - was everywhere and tried his heart out. 2 - Joffa - see above 1 - Laurie - solid Honourable mention to AD, Brooks and Tamou. Na...

2 years ago
Page 9 / 28