voice_of_reason
@voice_of_reason
Balmain Tigers SG Ball
Joined: February 5, 2022 9:47 am
Last seen: March 4, 2023 5:38 pm
Topics: 6 / Replies: 402
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Deardon is going to be a star - he has 'it'.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Even if I agreed - which I clearly don't - he's still barely in the top 10 and that's reliant on him improving. This is exactly why we struggle as a...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

For all who are convinced AD is a 6, seriously ask yourself how many teams would sign him to replace their current 6? Here's this week's five eighths:...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Despite his shirt he didn't play as a 6, we had him playing wider. His second half was good, first was bad.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

His best game was against us last year when he scored 3 or 4 tries. He's now played two good games in total. We already have one Panthers' fullback ...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Saying it doesn't make it so See above - they don't want to contradict him They shouldn't - nobody should be guaranteed a spot especially when the...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

What's really sad about this is he's both our best and cheapest half - and the only one who has a modicum of knowledge of leading a successful team. O...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Did Wests Tigers make the right choice?

In contrast, haven't both Sheens and Benji publicly proclaimed they're going to play an attacking, expansive style game?

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Signing Moses is trying to revive a successful lower grades pairing with zero certainty it will work 10 years later. I can't see it happening if Brook...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

Yes. AD is a poor defender so 13 is out. If anywhere up front it would be second row where he could run good lines.

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Wests Tigers Signings Discussion

I assume you mean (Hastings) doesn't want to play 13. Hastings meeting with Sheens probably revolved around Ciraldo being coach. Once that dissolved...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Jackson Hastings, is it all a show?

It's not only the forward pack, the current roster is a step or two below the better teams. Let's consider Hastings getting Salford to the grand fin...

2 years ago
Forum
NRL
Reply
RE: Jackson Hastings, is it all a show?

I should also point out, 1 through 6 are not exclusive to Hastings. The same applies for any combination of Madden, Brooks, AD, Nu Brown etc in the ...

2 years ago
Forum
NRL
Reply
RE: Live game day thread v Panthers Rd18 *Spoilers

We were getting belted by their forwards and he'd been worked to death. Your chief playmaker shouldn't be your top tackler. For comparison, DCE this...

2 years ago
Reply
RE: Jackson Hastings, is it all a show?

Good grief. 1. Hooker's job 2. Can only be done effectively when the forwards are going forward. When they're driven back there's nothing a half c...

2 years ago
Forum
NRL
Page 8 / 28