@celtic_tiger he just can't tackle period it was tanking I agree he just can't tackle at the best of times

@avocadoontoast Brooks was brought up because Declan said to me in his post Douhie is a better 6 than Brooks go back and have a look ....

@celtic_tiger including when he recieved halfback of the year got it fair dinkum

@celtic_tiger Douhies talent is a complete myth, him telling the club where he wants to play after tonight he shoukd be shaking hands with the Magpies...

@voice_of_reason plenty of rusted on supporters from the other forum have hammered him tonight

@helmesy reading his own press very poor attitude. i hope we don't sign him for 2024

@tiger5150 agree there Madden tried at least, Brooks tries doesn't always get it right but has a go Douhie, buggered off to souths then comes back a...

@tigersteve not popular to support old Brooksy on here Steve, some thought Madden was a suitable replacement

@voice_of_reason well said signed as a fullback and failed, now a 6 who can't make tackles think he is the bloke who goes in 2024

@celtic_tiger easy out for Sheens No Hastings and no Brooks essential members of our spine

@avocadoontoast disagree with that he wa the right fit in 2018 he is the right fit now with Hastings around

@avocadoontoast maybe we give Laurie a go at 6 agree and try for a fullback I think the only think in Brooks favour at the club is the long service...

@declan completely disagree douhie would have to be the worst defensive half in the comp. Brooks a far superior defender and has pace a better opt...

we better extend Hastings asap then worry about Brooks on a reduced deal Then go for a marquee 6

@declan You can't possibly defend Douhie at 6 his defence is pathetic