maybe not productive but looking at yesterday’s 17 and giving my gut view on whether we would ideally cut or keep based on whether a decent team would have this player in this position. No science just my personal view.
I have 7 keepers, 2 of which are leaving the club at the end of this season. Hastings is the only spine player I would keep and he would need a talented halves pairing to make up for his limited athletic ability.
1. Daine Laurie — cut
2. David Nofoaluma — keep
3. James Roberts — cut
4. Oliver Gildart — cut
5. Ken Maumalo — keep
6. Jackson Hastings — keep
7. Luke Brooks — cut
8. James Tamou — cut
9. Jake Simpkin — cut
10. Stefano Utoikamanu — keep
11. Kelma Tuilagi — keep
12. Luciano Leilua — keep
13. Joe Ofahengaue — cut.
14. Tyrone Peachey — cut
15. Alex Twal — cut.
16. Zane Musgrove — cut.
17. Alex Seyfarth — keep.
Stefano. The rest aren’t worth keeping imo.
Steph and Nofa are the only keepers for me. On Nofa, I don’t know why he no longer runs from dummy half after kick returns. He is damaging from there but now is taking runs one off the ruck and gets smashed. I’ll put this down to Madge.
maybe not productive but looking at yesterday’s 17 and giving my gut view on whether we would ideally cut or keep based on whether a decent team would have this player in this position. No science just my personal view.
I have 7 keepers, 2 of which are leaving the club at the end of this season. Hastings is the only spine player I would keep and he would need a talented halves pairing to make up for his limited athletic ability.
1. Daine Laurie — cut
2. David Nofoaluma — keep
3. James Roberts — cut
4. Oliver Gildart — cut
5. Ken Maumalo — keep
6. Jackson Hastings — keep
7. Luke Brooks — cut
8. James Tamou — cut
9. Jake Simpkin — cut
10. Stefano Utoikamanu — keep
11. Kelma Tuilagi — keep
12. Luciano Leilua — keep
13. Joe Ofahengaue — cut.14. Tyrone Peachey — cut
15. Alex Twal — cut.
16. Zane Musgrove — cut.
17. Alex Seyfarth — keep.
Two of your keepers are leavers .....and you want to keep Seyfarth ....
maybe not productive but looking at yesterday’s 17 and giving my gut view on whether we would ideally cut or keep based on whether a decent team would have this player in this position. No science just my personal view.
I have 7 keepers, 2 of which are leaving the club at the end of this season. Hastings is the only spine player I would keep and he would need a talented halves pairing to make up for his limited athletic ability.
1. Daine Laurie — cut
2. David Nofoaluma — keep
3. James Roberts — cut
4. Oliver Gildart — cut
5. Ken Maumalo — keep
6. Jackson Hastings — keep
7. Luke Brooks — cut
8. James Tamou — cut
9. Jake Simpkin — cut
10. Stefano Utoikamanu — keep
11. Kelma Tuilagi — keep
12. Luciano Leilua — keep
13. Joe Ofahengaue — cut.14. Tyrone Peachey — cut
15. Alex Twal — cut.
16. Zane Musgrove — cut.
17. Alex Seyfarth — keep.Two of your keepers are leavers .....
Yep, sorry @tigertownSFS but Kelma and Luciano are confirmed departures at the end of the year.
Wests Tigers Podcast - Talking everything Wests Tigers!
@helmesy yeah maybe post wasn’t clear but I acknowledged that the 2 of the 7 keepers were leaving. Point being we can’t even keep the ones that would actually have value to other teams whilst we fill out team with people no one would want.
To be really honest here we have too much pepper and not enough salt in the squad we have.
