@avocadoontoast Peachey at 9 I guess he can do a job, better than Liddle
I’m not too sure about that one guys… I could entertain Luke starting at 9 and Peachey on the bench though.
I’m just reluctant to split up Brooks and Hastings. I think we’re badly weakening one position to marginally strengthen another.
I’ve been a big brooks critic but he looked good at 6 yesterday.
This could possibly be the time to offload one of our hookers. I’ve been a fan of Liddle for a long time, but I think his time is up. Simpkin won’t play at least the next two, good chance to test Luke in the nine. We know his defence is up to it and it gives us a left foot boot out of dummy half aswell. Madden can do a good job at 6 also.
I think Liddle's service is way too slow. Simpkin had us on the front foot yesterday and it made a massive difference. It's a real shame he picked up an injury. Shame Rua can't play yet. I'd probably start Peachey at 9 and then have Rua come on later.
@avocadoontoast Peachey at 9 I guess he can do a job, better than Liddle
I’m not too sure about that one guys… I could entertain Luke starting at 9 and Peachey on the bench though.
I’m just reluctant to split up Brooks and Hastings. I think we’re badly weakening one position to marginally strengthen another.
I’ve been a big brooks critic but he looked good at 6 yesterday.
Totally agree. Id be tempted to throw Madden in there but Im not sure he could keep up in defence
No reason Brooks can't defend in the middle and play 6 in attack
2ndly you could alternate all 3 ( or 4 if you include Laurie ) depending on what happens or is planned with the attack ...you get on the front foot and alternate all 4 and run the Wabbits off their feet .....
But on the other side Cook is back in form and could kill us if they get on a roll
I think as others have said Liddles time is done he is not up to it
can we play Rua ? is he not part of the 30 man squad or it looks like Peachey plays there
I agree we need to keep Brooks and Hastings together at present.
Souths are short a front rower if Tamau and twal aim up we can run over them they arenreally light on up front
2nd best half of footy this season
An experienced captain should of came and spoke to the referee after knock on ...captains challenge and said " Look ref ...it is now plain to see you are reffing against us ...keep it up and we lodge a complaint " ...get in the refs head .....
It’s been terrible the officiating…. But what’s new! Have to make Hastings captain next week.
Maybe that’s a logical next step.
Need to build the club around AD, Hastings and Stef. They’re the future I think
After tonight do we give Brooks one last chance ......give him the whole season at 6 or 9 .....leave him there no matter what ....
Yeah I reckon mate. It was the best footy he and the team have played in a long time. Hopefully not a coincidence but worth shifting AD to another position if they continue on this path.
I think as others have said Liddles time is done he is not up to it
can we play Rua ? is he not part of the 30 man squad or it looks like Peachey plays there
I agree we need to keep Brooks and Hastings together at present.
Souths are short a front rower if Tamau and twal aim up we can run over them they arenreally light on up front
Rua isn't in the top 30 until next year.
In memory of Geoff Chisholm (1965-2022)
Here is a thought re Brooks
Hastings put the ball over the deadball line at the death, imagine if that was Brooks he would have been hung drawn and quartered.
Difference is Hastings took the moment by the scruff on the neck and kicked the field goal
@garry did you guys repost your live review of yesterday's game as yet ?
We didn't go live last night as Joel is away and he controls that aspect, Eddie and I did record a pod though and I will find out when it will be out.
In memory of Geoff Chisholm (1965-2022)
I think as others have said Liddles time is done he is not up to it
can we play Rua ? is he not part of the 30 man squad or it looks like Peachey plays there
I agree we need to keep Brooks and Hastings together at present.
Souths are short a front rower if Tamau and twal aim up we can run over them they arenreally light on up front
Rua isn't in the top 30 until next year.
Didn't we have a thread saying he was ......
@garry are reports correct that Joel is up in Darwin too ??
I think as others have said Liddles time is done he is not up to it
can we play Rua ? is he not part of the 30 man squad or it looks like Peachey plays there
I agree we need to keep Brooks and Hastings together at present.
Souths are short a front rower if Tamau and twal aim up we can run over them they arenreally light on up front
Rua isn't in the top 30 until next year.
@garry are reports correct that Joel is up in Darwin too ??
Did someone say honeymoon for Joel and Justin?
In memory of Geoff Chisholm (1965-2022)
I think as others have said Liddles time is done he is not up to it
can we play Rua ? is he not part of the 30 man squad or it looks like Peachey plays there
I agree we need to keep Brooks and Hastings together at present.
Souths are short a front rower if Tamau and twal aim up we can run over them they arenreally light on up front
Rua isn't in the top 30 until next year.
That is for next year.
In memory of Geoff Chisholm (1965-2022)
@garry did you guys repost your live review of yesterday's game as yet ?
We didn't go live last night as Joel is away and he controls that aspect, Eddie and I did record a pod though and I will find out when it will be out.
Will go up this afternoon.
In memory of Geoff Chisholm (1965-2022)
